TL;DR
Mark Ritson's position on the Effies is old, explicit and unusually blunt for an industry that treats all awards as roughly equivalent: the Effies are the ones with evidence behind them. In 2019 he wrote that they "enjoy a level of impact and rigour that all the other awards simply do not have."
At Cannes Lions 2025 he went further. He presented a preview of The Creative Dividend, a System1 and Effie Worldwide project built on the Effie Case Library and System1's ad-testing database. The argument: creative quality is not a cost centre, it is a commercial variable.
The published research covers 1,265 campaigns from 2007 to 2023, $139 billion in market share and more than 200,000 consumer responses. It reports that creative and media together explain 60.1% of business results on average, and up to 98.3% in certain categories.
The multiplier headlines do not agree with each other. 12x, 21x, 7x and $4.40 versus $7.10 all appear in coverage of the same body of work, and they measure different comparisons. Quoting one as if it were another is the mistake.
What Ritson actually said about the Effies
The clearest statement is a column Ritson wrote for Advertising Council Australia in September 2019. He was not hedging.
"But in a sea of gleaming marketing trophies and certificates, the Effies are special."
"The Effies enjoy a level of impact and rigour that all the other awards simply do not have."
He explained why: the Effies judge work against its objectives and its results, not against craft alone. That is the distinction he keeps returning to. A trophy for execution is one thing. A trophy for whether the work did what it was supposed to do is another.
"The Effies have marked the time of advertising and marketing."
On the Grand Effie, he was equally direct. Winning it signals:
"World class, best in the industry good."
And his closing line in that column:
"So there are lots of prizes for marketing and advertising. And then there are the Effies."
Campaign Canada reported in November 2019 that Ritson called the Effies the "gold standard" for marketing effectiveness and described a Grand Effie as "career making." That is the publication's report of his remarks rather than a transcript, but it is consistent with the column he wrote himself.
Cannes Lions 2025: the session
The Cannes session was titled "The Creative Dividend: Four Ads, Three Factors, and Two Bears." Ritson presented it on Thursday 19 June 2025 at 5pm on the Rotonde Stage.
It was a preview of a publication Effie Worldwide and System1 were preparing, "The Creative Dividend: Advertising That Pays Back." The data preview combined three things:
- the Effie Case Library, the archive of Effie entries and results;
- System1's emotion-first creative measurement database;
- fresh analysis of the latest Gold and Grand winners.
Ritson introduced a "Creativity Stack" of five evidence-based creative principles, and argued that the factors that make an ad effective are narrower and more teachable than the industry usually admits.
According to Roastbrief's report of the talk, he said creative quality can produce:
"up to 12 times more profit between the worst and best-performing ads," including "even within the same brand."
And he set out three requirements:
"To unlock the creative dividend, your ad needs three things:" emotion, fluency or distinctiveness, and time.
That is the argument in miniature. The creative dividend is not a promise that every ad can be a winner. It is a claim that the gap between the worst and best work is large enough to be a commercial problem, and that the ingredients of the better work are identifiable.
What the published research found
The book launched in New York on 27 January 2026. It is authored by Andrew Tindall of System1, under the System1 and Effie names.
The stable numbers, from Effie and System1's own pages, are:
- 1,265 campaigns, 2007 to 2023, across the US, Europe, UK and Ireland
- $139 billion in market share represented
- more than 200,000 consumer responses
- creative and media together explain 60.1% of campaign business results on average, and up to 98.3% in some categories
- 41% of marketers still see creativity as a business risk
- dull campaigns averaged $4.40 ROI against $7.10 for stronger work
- strong distinctiveness plus positive emotion made incremental profit 7x more likely at low spend
- distinctiveness with large budgets raised the likelihood of revenue growth by 29 percentage points
- brand consistency declined by 25% over ten years
Ritson's comment on the finished work, as quoted by System1, was that it contains "genuinely original thinking and big ideas" and is "immediately applicable."
The numbers are not interchangeable
This is where most coverage of the report goes wrong.
- 12x is the reported gap between the worst and best-performing ads in the analysis, including within the same brand. It is a comparison of extremes.
- 21x was reported by Campaign Brief in June 2025 as "creativity's profit multiplier." That is a different framing of the same body of work, and it was published before the final book.
- 7x is a conditional likelihood: distinctiveness plus positive emotion made incremental profit seven times more likely at low spend. It is not a blanket multiplier.
- $4.40 versus $7.10 is a return-on-investment comparison between dull and strong creative. That is roughly 1.6x, not 12x.
- 60.1% is the share of campaign business results that creative and media explain together in this dataset. It is not a claim that creativity alone causes 60.1% of growth.
All of these can be true at once because they answer different questions. The honest sentence is not "Ritson proved creativity multiplies profit 12 times." It is: in this dataset, the best ads returned up to twelve times the profit of the worst, and the size of the gap depends on which comparison you make.
The counter-argument
Not everyone accepted the framing. Byron Sharp responded in Marketing Week on 25 March 2026 with a column titled "The 'creative dividend'? More like creative accounting."
The title tells you the direction. Anyone using the 60.1% figure should read that column alongside the original research, because the difference between "creative and media explain 60.1% of campaign business results in this sample" and "creativity drives 60.1% of business results" is the whole argument. The first is a statistical description. The second is a causal claim the data does not make on its own.
That is not a reason to dismiss the research. It is a reason to describe it accurately.
Why the Effies matter in this argument
The Effies are not central to this story because awards are nice. They are central because they are one of the few databases that records what a campaign was trying to do and whether it worked.
That is what makes them usable as evidence. Cannes juries reward craft. The Effies record objectives and outcomes. When System1 wanted to test whether creative quality predicts commercial results, the Effie archive was the place to look, because it contains the outcome side of the equation.
Ritson's 2019 claim and his 2025 presentation are the same argument at different levels of resolution. The first says the Effies are the awards with rigour. The second uses that rigour as a dataset.
Listen to the argument in full
Mark Ritson was the first guest on Boringly Effective, recorded at Cannes Lions 2026, on pricing, brand building and the boring work of marketing effectiveness.
- Listen to the episode with Mark Ritson
- Mark Ritson: profile and interviews
- Marketing effectiveness: the complete guide
- The Long and the Short of It: what Binet & Field really found
Sources
- Mark Ritson, "Adjunct Professor Mark Ritson on why the Effies are special," Advertising Council Australia, 11 September 2019. https://advertisingcouncil.org.au/news/adjunct-professor-mark-ritson-on-why-the-effies-are-special/
- Campaign Canada, "Here's What Drives Advertising Effectiveness," 20 November 2019. https://www.campaigncanada.ca/article/1852889/heres-drives-advertising-effectiveness
- Effie Worldwide, "The Creative Dividend @ Cannes Lions," 2025. https://effie.org/events/the-creative-dividend-cannes-lions/
- Roastbrief US, "Effie @ Cannes Lions 2025," 11 June 2025. https://roastbrief.us/effie-cannes-lions-2025/
- Roastbrief US, "Mark Ritson at Cannes Lions 2025: The Creative Dividend Is Real—Here's How to Earn It," 1 July 2025. https://roastbrief.us/mark-ritson-at-cannes-lions-2025-the-creative-dividend-is-real-heres-how-to-earn-it/
- Effie Worldwide, "System1 and Effie Launch The Creative Dividend," 27 January 2026. https://effie.org/news/system1-and-effie-launch-the-creative-dividend-a-practical-guide-to-making-effectiveness-happen-in-advertising-today/
- System1, "The Creative Dividend," 2026. https://system1group.com/the-creative-dividend
- Effie Insights, "The Creative Dividend: Advertising That Pays Back," 2026. https://effie.org/insights/the-creative-dividend-advertising-that-pays-back/
- Campaign Brief, "System1 and Effie Worldwide launch groundbreaking report – 'The Creative Dividend'," 25 June 2025. https://campaignbrief.com/system1-and-effie-worldwide-launch-groundbreaking-report-the-creative-dividend/
- Byron Sharp, "The 'creative dividend'? More like creative accounting," Marketing Week, 25 March 2026.